Bread · Any · Intermediate

Challah

Braided Egg Bread for Shabbat & Holidays

A deep-bronze braid under a lacquered egg-wash sheen, tearing into long tender strands — faintly sweet, perfumed with yeast and toasted sesame, still warm at the crumb.

10serves

5 h 30 mintotal time

53 minhands-on

9dishes

2 dmake ahead

Per serving ≈ 305 cal · 8g protein · 10g fat · 44g carbs

Friday afternoon at the cabin has a smell, and this is it: yeast and toasted egg wash pulling everyone off the porch and into the kitchen while the light goes long. The braid is the week's exhale — twenty patient minutes with your hands in something soft after five days of screens. We bake two, because the Sabbath table asks for two loaves, and because the second one rarely survives to Saturday.

Cooking around dairy, gluten, wine, meat…? tap to adjust

The Tools

Kitchen scale — Flour, water, and the egg all matter by weight — this is a formula, not a cup-measure
Large mixing bowl — Mixes the dough and doubles as the rising bowl, lightly oiled
Small bowl (proof the yeast)
Fork or small whisk — Beats the dough eggs and the wash
Bench scraper — Divides the dough into even strands and lifts tacky dough cleanly off the counter
Stand mixer with dough hook (optional) — Optional — kneads the enriched dough in ~8 minutes; the taught method here is by hand
Half-sheet pan
Parchment paper
Pastry brush — For the two egg washes; silicone or natural bristle
Plastic wrap or a clean damp towel — Covers the dough through both rises
Instant-read thermometer (optional) — 190°F is doneness; the color of an egg-washed loaf lies
Wire rack
Serrated bread knife

✚ ends up in the sink · essentials unless marked optional

The Enriched Dough

Yields About 940g dough — one large braided loaf Make 0–2 days ahead

Why this works Enriched means fat, egg, and sugar are folded into a basic bread dough, and each one changes the game. Egg yolk and oil coat the gluten strands so the baked crumb is soft and tender instead of chewy-lean — but that same fat lubrication also slows gluten from linking up, which is why enriched dough needs a longer, more committed knead than a plain loaf. Sugar feeds the yeast at first, then works against it: at 12% it draws water osmotically away from the yeast cells and holds the rise back, so the formula runs a modest 1.4% yeast and a patient rise rather than a fast, yeasty one — the slow ferment is where challah's bread flavor is built, not lost. Bread flour is the non-negotiable — its 12–13% protein builds the strong, extensible gluten network that lets a strand stretch to fourteen inches without tearing and gives challah its signature pull. Salt at 2% tightens that gluten and reins in the yeast so the flavor is bread, not beer. As baker's percentages (flour = 100%): water 28%, whole egg 30%, oil 16%, sugar 12%, yeast 1.4%, salt 2%. And it is made with oil, never butter, by design: that keeps it pareve — neither meat nor dairy — so it can sit on any Shabbat table, including a meat one. Water at ~100°F wakes the yeast; above ~120°F kills it.

140g (a scant 2/3 cup), warm to the touch, not hot Warm water (~100°F) 140 g — Body temperature — comfortable on the wrist. Hotter than ~120°F kills the yeast
7g (2 1/4 tsp, one packet) Instant or active-dry yeast 7 g — Active-dry MUST proof in the warm water first; instant technically needn't, but we proof it anyway as cheap insurance
60g (5 tbsp), divided Granulated sugar 60 g — A spoonful jump-starts the yeast; the rest goes into the dough. Honey works too — swap gram for gram and cut the water by 1 tbsp, but honey adds an animal product
3 (150g), room temperature Large eggs 150 g — Cold eggs stiffen the dough and slow the rise — bring them out 30 minutes ahead. Swapping one white for a second yolk deepens the color and softens the crumb
80g (about 6 tbsp) Neutral oil (canola or grapeseed) 80 g — Neutral, not olive — olive oil reads savory and fights the gentle sweetness. Oil keeps the loaf pareve
500g (about 4 cups, spooned and leveled) Bread flour 500 g — 12–13% protein. All-purpose works but the braid is softer-edged and the chew is weaker
10g (1 3/4 tsp fine sea salt, or 1 tbsp Diamond Crystal kosher) Fine sea salt 10 g — Keep it off direct contact with the proofing yeast — dissolve it into the flour side

Proof the yeast 2 min hands-on · 8 min wait

Warm water into the small bowl with 1 tbsp of the sugar and the yeast. Stir once and leave it 5–10 minutes.

Look for A foamy, creamy raft rises on the surface and it smells bready. That's living yeast.

Take care Flat and lifeless after 10 minutes means dead yeast or water that was too hot — start over, or the loaf never rises.
Build the wet 3 min hands-on

In the large bowl, beat the eggs with a fork, then whisk in the oil and the remaining sugar. Pour in the foamy yeast-water and stir to combine.
Add flour and salt 4 min hands-on

Add about 90% of the flour and all the salt. Stir with the fork, then your hand, into a shaggy, rough mass. Hold back the last of the flour to judge the dough by feel.

Look for No dry pockets of flour left; a sticky, ragged ball that barely clears the sides of the bowl.
Knead the enriched dough 12 min hands-on

Turn onto a clean counter and knead 10–12 minutes by hand (or 8 minutes on a stand mixer's dough hook, medium). Add flour a teaspoon at a time only if it's truly gluey — enriched dough stays tacky and resists longer than a lean dough, so keep going past the point you'd expect.

Look for Smooth, supple, and elastic; tacky but not sticky; it passes the windowpane test — a pinch stretched thin lets light through before it tears.

Take care Under-kneaded dough tears when you braid it and bakes dense; over-flouring makes it dry and tough. When in doubt, knead longer rather than flour more.
Bulk rise 2 min hands-on · 1 h 45 min wait

Wipe the bowl, film it with oil, return the dough turned to coat, and cover. Rise in a warm spot 1.5–2 hours until doubled. For deeper flavor, rise 30 minutes at room temperature then refrigerate overnight, and pull it out 1 hour before shaping.

Look for Doubled in volume; a floured fingertip poked in springs back slowly and leaves a shallow dent that stays.

Take care A cold room stalls the rise for hours — find warmth (an oven with only the light on) rather than adding more yeast.

When it goes wrong

Problem	Cause	Fix
Dough barely rose	Dead yeast, a cold room, or too much flour worked in	Confirm the proof foams before committing; rise somewhere warm; weigh the flour rather than scooping
Dough stays soupy and won't come together	Too little flour, or the knead stopped before gluten set	Add flour a teaspoon at a time and keep kneading — enriched dough tightens late in the knead, not early
Strands tear when you try to roll them	Under-developed gluten	Knead a few more minutes to a clean windowpane, then rest the dough 10 minutes before rolling

The Braid, Proof & Bake

Yields One large braided loaf, ~10 slices

Why this works A three-strand braid is the one taught here because it can be described exactly and it never fails; the plump six-strand loaf you see in bakeries is the same over-the-middle logic with more ropes and a memorized position sequence — worth learning from a video once the three-strand is muscle memory. Three moves make it look professional. First, even strand thickness bakes evenly and reads deliberate. Second, taper each rope thinner at the ends so the braid has a fat belly and tucks-under tips, which is what gives challah its dome. Third — the one nobody tells you — braid from the CENTER outward toward each end rather than top to bottom: pinch the ropes together in the middle, braid one half, flip, braid the other. Working end-to-end drags the loaf lopsided and thins one tip; center-out comes out symmetric and high. Tension is a Goldilocks number: braid too tight and the proof can't expand the weave, so it splits in the oven; too loose and it bakes flat. The second proof stops a hair short of full on purpose — a slightly underproofed loaf still has yeast in reserve and gives one last burst of oven spring, while an overproofed one has spent itself and collapses to a flat, wrinkled, faintly sour braid. The double egg wash is two different jobs: a thin first coat right after shaping seals the surface so it can't skin and crack during the proof; a second, generous coat right before baking builds the mahogany lacquer (Maillard browning of egg protein and the loaf's own sugars) and glues the seeds on. Enriched, sugary dough browns and is done sooner than lean bread — pull it at 190°F internal, not the 205°F of a baguette, or the sugar and egg dry out and toughen.

all of it (~940g) Risen dough — From the component above
1, beaten with 1 tsp water and a pinch of salt Large egg (wash) — The salt breaks the egg down so it brushes on thin and even instead of ropey
2 tbsp (about 16g) Sesame or poppy seeds — Optional but traditional; scatter generously while the second wash is wet

Divide into three 4 min hands-on

Turn the risen dough out and gently press the big bubbles down. Cut it into 3 equal pieces with the bench scraper — weigh them, ~315g each, so the braid comes out even.

Look for Three matched pieces; a scale removes the guesswork that shows up as a lopsided braid.
Roll the strands 8 min hands-on · 5 min wait

Roll each piece under flat palms into a rope 14–16 inches long, fatter through the middle and tapered at both ends. If a rope springs back and won't lengthen, set it down, roll the others, and come back — the gluten needs a minute to relax.

Look for Even, air-free ropes (pat out any big trapped bubbles) with tapered tips.

Take care Work on a barely-floured, dry counter — the ropes need to grip to lengthen. Too much flour and they slide and refuse to stretch.
Braid from the center out 9 min hands-on

Lay the three ropes side by side and pinch them together at the MIDDLE, not the top. Braid one half to the end — bring the outer strand over the middle strand, alternate sides, keep the tension even — then pinch the tips and tuck them under. Turn the loaf around and braid the other half the same way; pinch and tuck.

Look for A symmetric, plump braid tapering to two tucked-under ends; tight enough to hold, loose enough that you can still see the gaps that will close during the proof.

Take care Braiding top-to-bottom instead of center-out drags the loaf crooked and thins one end; yanking the strands tight now makes the loaf split in the oven.
First wash and final proof 3 min hands-on · 50 min wait

Lift the braid onto a parchment-lined sheet pan. Brush a thin coat of egg wash over the whole surface to seal it, cover loosely, and proof 45–60 minutes until puffy and grown by about half.

Look for Visibly puffed and jiggly when you shake the pan; a lightly floured finger pressed into the side leaves a dent that fills back slowly.

Take care If the dent springs back instantly it's underproofed — give it more time. If it doesn't fill at all and the loaf sighs, it's overproofed and will bake flat; get it into the oven immediately rather than proofing further.
Preheat, second wash, seeds 3 min hands-on

Heat the oven to 350°F (175°C). Brush a second, more generous coat of egg wash, working it into the seams without letting it pool. Shower the top with sesame or poppy seeds while it's wet.

Take care Wash pooled in the crevices bakes into scrambled-egg patches — brush thin and dab up any puddles.
Bake to 190°F 2 min hands-on · 34 min wait

Bake on the center rack at 350°F for 30–38 minutes. Once it's deep gold — around the 20-minute mark — tent it loosely with foil so the wash stops darkening while the inside finishes.

Look for Deep mahogany and glossy, hollow-sounding when tapped underneath, and 190°F on a thermometer pushed into the center.

Take care Egg and sugar brown fast — color is not doneness. Trust 190°F: pulled early it's gummy inside, left too long it dries out.
Cool before slicing 1 min hands-on · 55 min wait

Slide the loaf onto a wire rack and let it cool at least 45–60 minutes before cutting.

Look for Cool enough to rest against the back of your hand; the crumb has stopped steaming.

Take care Slicing hot compresses the still-setting crumb into a gummy smear — wait, even though it smells impossible to.

When it goes wrong

Problem	Cause	Fix
Loaf baked flat and spread out	Overproofed, or gluten under-developed in the knead	Proof to barely puffy with a slow-filling dent, not maximum; knead to a clean windowpane next time
Pale or matte crust, no shine	Skipped the second wash, or the oven ran low	Two washes always; verify the oven with a thermometer — many run 25°F cool
Braid split open along a seam in the oven	Underproofed, or the strands were braided too tight	Give the loaf its full proof and braid with even, gentle tension so the weave can expand

To the Table

Bring the whole loaf to the table on a board, tucked ends down, and let it be seen before it's torn — the braid is the point.
For Shabbat, set out two loaves (lechem mishneh); this recipe makes one, so double the dough or bake two smaller braids.
Slice thick with a serrated knife in a sawing motion, or tear it by hand at the table while it's still faintly warm.
Serve with flaky salt and good olive oil, or with honey for Rosh Hashanah. Butter is wonderful but adds dairy — keep the loaf pareve at a meat meal by reaching for oil or honey instead.
Save the heels and any day-old slices: challah is the finest bread there is for French toast and bread pudding. Never bin it.

For the Cook Who Wants More

The Honest Ledger

Serves	10
Shopping	20 min
Hands-on (new to this)	1 h 25 min
Hands-on (comfortable)	1 h 6 min
Hands-on (experienced)	53 min
Waiting (same for everyone)	4 h 17 min
True total	5 h 30 min
You will dirty	9 dishes

A thick slice eats like a rich dinner roll, not a dessert — the sweetness is restrained (12% sugar), and the richness comes from egg and oil rather than butter, which is also what keeps it pareve. Most of the load is carbohydrate; the crumb carries real protein from whole egg and bread flour. Day-old slices become French toast, not waste.

Words We Used

Enriched dough: A bread dough with fat, egg, and sugar worked in — softer, richer, faster to brown, and longer-keeping than a lean dough of only flour, water, salt, and yeast.
Pareve: In kosher practice, a food that is neither meat nor dairy and so may be eaten with either. Challah is made with oil rather than butter precisely to stay pareve.
Baker's percentage: Expressing every ingredient as a percentage of the flour weight (flour = 100%) so a formula scales cleanly and can be compared at a glance.
Windowpane test: Stretching a pinch of dough thin enough to pass light without tearing — the sign that the gluten is fully developed.
Bulk fermentation: The first rise, when the whole mass of dough ferments and roughly doubles before it's shaped.
Poke test: Pressing a floured finger into proofed dough: a slow, partial spring-back means it's ready; instant spring-back means underproofed; no spring-back means overproofed.
Oven spring: The fast final rise in the first minutes of baking, as trapped gas expands and the yeast gives a last push before the heat sets the crust.
Egg wash: Beaten egg brushed on before baking for shine and deep color and to glue on seeds; the browning is a Maillard reaction between the egg's proteins and the loaf's sugars.
Lechem mishneh: The two loaves set on the Shabbat table, recalling the double portion of manna gathered before the Sabbath.

← Back to the table